Every Stone Tells a Story

For far too long, diamonds have dominated the expression of romantic love. At Martin Nagel Manufacturing Jewellers, we believe that the stone chooses the person—and there’s simply no reason to limit yourself to diamonds alone, even if it is forever…

Of course, one undeniable benefit of a diamond is its incredible durability. With a solid 10/10 on the Mohs scale of hardness, it’s perfectly suited for the everyday wear of an engagement or wedding ring. But that’s not to say that other gemstones aren’t equally valid choices.

Our simple suggestion? Consider your daily lifestyle and activities before choosing your forever stone. This will help determine whether a softer gem is suitable for everyday wear, or if you should opt for something more durable, like a diamond or, in fact, a sapphire.

With so much variety in alternative gemstones, it’s essential to work with a trusted, reputable jeweller who knows how to distinguish a quality gem from a lacklustre one.

First and Foremost: Find Your Perfect Cut

Gemstones are available in a wide range of cuts, each with its own pros and cons. Ultimately, your choice comes down to personal taste.

Once you’ve determined your preferred cut, the next step is to select the stone itself—followed by the most complementary metal and design.

Popular Diamond Alternatives

AQUAMARINE
The perfect "something blue" for the big day. Aquamarine is a classic and elegant stone, and its soft, pastel tone makes it a timeless choice for couples investing in an heirloom.
Hardness rating: 7.5–8

EMERALD
Striking and sophisticated, the emerald is for those who want something a little different—without straying too far from tradition.
Hardness rating: 7.5

MORGANITE
This blush-toned gem has become a favourite for its feminine, modern feel. As a member of the same gem family as aquamarine, it's ideal for light, everyday wear.
Hardness rating: 7.5–8

RUBY
For the glamorous at heart, rubies are known as the gemstones of love. With shades ranging from vibrant pink to deep burgundy, rubies pair beautifully with both bold and subtle designs.
Hardness rating: 9

SAPPHIRE
Deep, dramatic, and daring. Sapphires carry a rich sense of history and mystery, making them a perfect choice for those who want to make a statement. Plus, they redefine the meaning of “something blue.”
Hardness rating: 9

AMETHYST
Not a fan of tradition? Swap “something blue” for something purple. While amethyst is on the softer side, it’s perfect for the unconventional wearer who isn’t too hard on their hands.
Hardness rating: 7

Looking for a stone that truly speaks to you?
Book a free consultation with Martin Nagel Manufacturing Jewellers to learn more about gemstone options and custom design.